The IRS’s Power Over Crypto Transactions: The Case of Coinbase User James Harper

CryptoMode IRS Tax Delays Tax Evasion

In a landmark decision poised to send ripples across the cryptocurrency market, the judicial system has affirmed the authority of the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) to retrieve personal data from the cryptocurrency exchange, Coinbase. This ruling underscores the IRS’s rigorous authority in its relentless pursuit of tax compliance. It provides a vivid narrative of a power dynamic where the IRS emerged victorious against a crypto user’s accusations of a privacy breach.

The Courtroom Drama: A Crypto User versus the IRS

A critical court session witnessed District Court Judge Joseph N. Laplante overrule the objections by James Harper, a crypto user contesting the IRS’s acquisition of his personal information. 

Laplante ruled that the IRS’s methods, including extracting personal information via a summons, did not infringe upon Harper’s rights to a fair trial or protection from unjust searches and confiscations. This ruling reinforced the IRS’s comprehensive jurisdiction, permitting it to issue summonses under various circumstances.

Check out our weekly crypto and fintech newsletter here! Follow CryptoMode on Twitter, Youtube and TikTok for news updates!

A salient facet of the case lay in Harper’s argument. He declared his privacy rights were infringed, an assertion that garnered minimal support in the context of interpreting the Fourth Amendment. 

Moreover, Judge Laplante noted that Harper had willingly offered his data to Coinbase. Coupled with the fact that Coinbase’s privacy policy forewarned users of potential government requisitions, this significantly weakened Harper’s stance as his disclosure to Coinbase was a voluntary act.

Alleged Fifth Amendment Violations: Harper’s Unsuccessful Assertion

Further, Laplante negated Harper’s claim of a Fifth Amendment rights violation, pointing out that ample opportunities were provided to contest or limit the summons. Harper had a decade-long association with Coinbase, starting in 2013 when he began depositing Bitcoin earnings from consultation services.

By 2016, to uphold transparency and adherence to regulations within the crypto market, the IRS requested information from Coinbase via a John Doe summons, aimed at unidentified taxpayers. Coinbase initially resisted this summons, which resulted in a second legal pursuit by the IRS to enforce compliance. That triggered a lengthy legal battle, culminating in Coinbase handing the required documents to the IRS.

Harper retaliated in 2018 by filing a lawsuit, raising several constitutional issues and demanding the IRS to erase his records. The First Circuit supported Harper’s argument based on the Anti-Injunction Act, notwithstanding the initial dismissal of his case. Despite this, Harper’s latest attempt to dispute the dismissal of his case in February fell short.

The Final Judgment: IRS’s Victory and Harper’s Dashed Hopes

In the most recent judgment, Laplante sided with the IRS, stating that Harper held no standing to claim an interest in the records under the Fourth or Fifth Amendments. The judge weakened Harper’s privacy violation claim by asserting that Coinbase was the legitimate custodian of Harper’s account documents. 

Furthermore, the judge negated Harper’s claim of a due process violation, stating that Harper lacked property rights over the records.

Regardless of alleged rights, the summonses were restricted and required court approval. Additional opportunities were available for Harper to challenge the summonses post-issuance, including during the court proceedings following Coinbase’s refusal to comply.

Coinbase issues Forms 1099-MISC to the IRS for US traders who made over $600 in crypto rewards or staking for the tax year 2022. If specific qualifying criteria are met, Coinbase may issue Form 1099-MISC to the account owner and the IRS, providing detailed information on taxable income from cryptocurrency transactions without including capital gains or losses.

None of the information on this website is investment or financial advice. CryptoMode is not responsible for any financial losses sustained by acting on information provided on this website.